<whitequark>
that at least seems like a topic I can discuss :)
<whitequark>
hm
<lekernel>
oh, you actually learn a lot attending conferences outside your domain :)
<whitequark>
lekernel: I'd still like to have a reason of attending
<whitequark>
right now, I'm neck deep in programming languages...
<lekernel>
even if it means asking stupid questions during cocktails (which of course you can indulge in as well without a ticket, especially if the conference costs over 1000E)
<wpwrak>
viric: there was a little power hickup (probably < 1 s). ups tried to fill in. so it switched over, but then the ups-provided power collapsed, resetting my workstation. all the other systems (not connected a ups) didn't even notice the brief interruption.
<whitequark>
wpwrak: I think that's called "precondition failure"
<whitequark>
$ ups blame # => wpwrak
<whitequark>
:p
<viric>
wpwrak: ok, I thought it was more a software issue
deceivorz has quit []
<whitequark>
lekernel: though. it occured to me that a fair amount of attendees would probably be clueless (of technical details) business people.
<wpwrak>
once upon a time, the imposters pretended to be doctors doing live-critical medical procedures, or pilots flying around the world (see Frank Abagnale). nowadays, they sneak into expensive conferences ...
<lekernel>
whitequark, that actually becomes an advantage when gatecrashing. then just engage the BS-filter.
<larsc>
the filter or the canon?
<wpwrak>
a BS generator seems to be most useful in such situations
<wpwrak>
else, you'll just stand in a corner without anyone to talk to
<wpwrak>
well, that diminishes the risk of detection
<whitequark>
lekernel: yeah yeah, that's what I'm saying
<lekernel>
the difficulty is switching quickly between filter and cannon. so you get to suck info about lithography or whatever topic the conference is about, while still going undetected.
<whitequark>
cannon?
<lekernel>
yeah, that thing you use when somone asks you what professor brought you there
jekhor has joined #qi-hardware
baba has quit [Quit: WeeChat 0.4.0]
panda|x201 has joined #qi-hardware
jekhor has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
freemor has joined #qi-hardware
porchaso0 has joined #qi-hardware
porchao has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
panda|x201 has quit [Ping timeout: 246 seconds]
jekhor has joined #qi-hardware
xdpirate has joined #qi-hardware
xiangfu has joined #qi-hardware
kilae has joined #qi-hardware
unclouded has quit [Ping timeout: 240 seconds]
LunaVorax has joined #qi-hardware
FDCX has joined #qi-hardware
xiangfu has quit [Quit: leaving]
<LunaVorax>
Hello everyone
<LunaVorax>
The Qi news hasn't been updated for two years, is Qi dying? What's happenning? Isn't there anything interesting for the past two years?
<LunaVorax>
So why the RSS fee of Qi-Hardware.com isn't updated about it, do you need a hand?
<lekernel>
yeah, if you have access to it, please do
<LunaVorax>
I don't
<LunaVorax>
Also, I don't know if Qi-Hardware is reday to take some suggestions about an eventual Ben Nanonote 2
<lekernel>
I don't think anyone is working on the NN2, and Wolfgang is MIA
<LunaVorax>
mia?
<lekernel>
missing in action
<LunaVorax>
oh ok
wej has quit [Ping timeout: 245 seconds]
megha has joined #qi-hardware
wej has joined #qi-hardware
<larsc>
I wouldn't say he's missing, but I think he has a lot of other things on his hands these days
Calyp has joined #qi-hardware
emeb has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
porchao has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp has quit [Ping timeout: 248 seconds]
porchaso0 has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 276 seconds]
panda|x201 has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
LunaVorax: the most important input regarding a Ben2 would be money ;-) i think the technical side is quite understood at the moment, but nobody has the resources to actually implement it.
pcercuei has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 245 seconds]
<lekernel>
use kickstarter! not a solution? ;)
<LunaVorax>
lekernel is right imho, have you never thought about using kickstarter wpwrak?
<LunaVorax>
It'll be worth a try
<wpwrak>
kickstarter is producing things you already have. you still have to finance the prototype.
<wpwrak>
s/ is / is for /
<qi-bot>
wpwrak meant: "kickstarter is for producing things you already have. you still have to finance the prototype."
<wpwrak>
you'd also need someone who manages the finances, etc. and with kickstarter, at least some of that work has to be done in the US.
<lekernel>
and producing a palatable video and content is itself a major effort
<wpwrak>
add the PR effort to making the prototype.
<wpwrak>
i'd say making the prototype would cost something in the order of USD 100k-200k
<lekernel>
it has to go through the curators, then have appeal to the masses who provably use fucked up criteria to judge projects
<wpwrak>
well, there's that risk as well. but since you're already moving a considerable amount of money, you could probably include a first run as well. keep the BOM cost low, of course. then you may be able to do a run of 2000-3000 units by raising your budget by 50%.
<larsc>
you think there is a market for 3000 units?
<wpwrak>
so that means no expensive experiments and moderate specs. main objective would be to avoid mistakes like not having USB host, putting in a better (wider) screen, getting control over the mechanics. no bleeding edge cpu and such. that only wastes resources.
<lekernel>
why not? rpi sold millions (-:C
<wpwrak>
there's probably a market for a lot more if you spin it right.
<lekernel>
or ouya, or ...
<wpwrak>
if you have full control over the design, you can also sell it as a building block. you can also offer fabrication services - combine smaller orders for modified designs. and so on. there's a lot of things you can do once you've mastered the ownership barrier.
<wpwrak>
also, work the DIY market a bit more. sort of like a more effective alternative to arduino + WiFI/BT + smartphone
<wpwrak>
of course, with the cost of the smartphone = 0, that's a bit tricky
<lekernel>
how many people do arduino + WiFI/BT + smartphone?
<lekernel>
this sounds like behind headed toward marketing failure
<LunaVorax>
Not to be mean or anything, but everytime the discussion of gathering funds is brought on the table, there's always a good reason NOT to do anything and the conclusion always end up with something like Qi-Hardware won't produce anything ever or something like that.
<wpwrak>
all those who need a reasonably fancy control interface and don't know how to build one from the ground up
<LunaVorax>
Not that I don't understand, but it always sounds like Qi is doomed or something
<wpwrak>
LunaVorax: your impression may not be incorrect
<LunaVorax>
It's a disaster then imho
<lekernel>
Qi lacks some "cool" factor, yes
<wpwrak>
qi-hw ran off wolfgang's money to finance product development and a lot of "free" engineering time by various volunteers
<LunaVorax>
Define cool factor lekernel
<lekernel>
being capable of producing mediocre devices like rpi and then selling millions
<wpwrak>
now that wolfgang is done (and probably close to broke) and people don't have much time anymore, things don't look particularly good
<LunaVorax>
Is copyleft hardware a doomed idea then?
<wpwrak>
s/done/gone/
<qi-bot>
wpwrak meant: "now that wolfgang is gone (and probably close to broke) and people don't have much time anymore, things don't look particularly good"
<LunaVorax>
I mean in a liberal capitalist society
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
<LunaVorax>
liberal as in liberalism, not "left"
<lekernel>
copyleft is a factor orders of magnitude less important than marketing
<lekernel>
as far as money is concerned
<LunaVorax>
hum
<larsc>
the rpi probably would have sold as well as it does even if it had been copyleft hardware
<LunaVorax>
Money over freedom…
<LunaVorax>
larsc is right I think
<LunaVorax>
Still it should have stayed as cheap
<lekernel>
that's a more positive way of sayning it ...
<lekernel>
s/sayning/saying
<qi-bot>
lekernel meant: "that's a more positive way of saying it ..."
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 276 seconds]
<larsc>
being copyleft is not really a killerfeature
<wpwrak>
copyleft is less of a game changes in hardware because of the inherent cost of doing things
<larsc>
so your product needs to be good
<LunaVorax>
What makes it good at the end is the software that runs it
<LunaVorax>
imho
<lekernel>
wpwrak, even outside of hardware. software support for rpi or, as I was noticing the hard way yesterday, ftdi-chip is far from stellar
<wpwrak>
in sw, it radically changes the cost structure. in hw, it's at best a major reduction of a cost that's still large.
<wpwrak>
lekernel: well yes, that's one of the costs of non-open systems :)
<LunaVorax>
I always think about the GCW-Zero, which is a pimped-up dingoo, but on the end what makes it great is the GNU/Linux distribution that it runs
<wpwrak>
LunaVorax: the problem is that most of the "cool" software can also run on a proprietary base
<wpwrak>
LunaVorax: the value of free software is in the longer run. e.g., being able to keep your 3 years old device supplied with new stuff
<lekernel>
mixxeo cannot :) but of course it's a niche market
<lekernel>
doesn't mean it won't work money-wise, though
<wpwrak>
as long as your planning horizon is < 1 year, it's very hard to convince you of free software. and with < 1 year, you're also not someone who builds things
<wpwrak>
(of free sw in relation to hw, so freedom-friendly hw, but not necessarily open hardware)
<LunaVorax>
So
<LunaVorax>
What heppens next?
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
<lekernel>
as far as I'm concerned, make a device that cannot be easily done with traditional proprietary parts, and get the UX/design/product part right this time
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 252 seconds]
panda|x201 has quit [Ping timeout: 248 seconds]
<lekernel>
and get out of the hacker/floss-directed stuff, it's a niche market *and* they are cheap bastards, so ...
<LunaVorax>
cheap bastards?
<LunaVorax>
Anyway can you generally precise your thoughts lekernel?
<lekernel>
who's buying a LEON ASIC? hmm? it's a GPL'd chip :)
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 246 seconds]
<wpwrak>
of course, if you require openness to be an enabler, the hacker/floss corner is quite important
<lekernel>
yes, all the "open source" hardware for hackers that sells is merely tiny microcontroller kits
<wpwrak>
you can try educational, but that's tough market
<wpwrak>
hacker/floss is also important to bring down development cost. if you have to pay for everything yourself, it gets a lot more expensive
<LunaVorax>
This all "market" thing seems fake imho. For exemple the Rpi was designed for the "educationnal market" but now everyone is having one
<LunaVorax>
Versatile products have versatile customers
paul_boddie has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
you still need to reach the people who buy them :-) but yes, sometimes a product meant for a given group can reach a lot more people
<LunaVorax>
I'm sure that if the Ben2 is well designed and advertised it could reach a lot of people
<wpwrak>
but you need that group you're reasonably certain of for securing the initial funding. that is, unless you finance yourself exclusively through crowdfunding. but then your focus determines how you present the product.
<wpwrak>
so you can't simply dodge that question
<lekernel>
it's versatile because it's cheap, and it's cheap because broadcom sells huge quantities of the SoC on that breakout board to put them in mobile phones etc.
<wpwrak>
well, picking an inexpensive chip isn't that hard. even the ben did that ;-)
<lekernel>
had rpi been designed entirely by the rpi foundation, including the chip, the cost per unit would probably be a lot more even with one million sold
<wpwrak>
i don't think it makes sense to design asics for this sort of devices
<LunaVorax>
Somehow
<wpwrak>
maybe that was something feasible in the days of the sinclair zx80 or maybe even the commodore amiga, but i doubt you can usefully compete with ingenic, allwinner, or even freescale
<lekernel>
therefore copyleft asics are for expensive niche markets, and expensive is incompatible with most of the hacker community
<LunaVorax>
Replacing the "phone" buttons by other label
mog has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
<wpwrak>
non-clamshell would make the device a bit bulky. but yes, it would simplify the mechanical design.
<LunaVorax>
Indeed
<wpwrak>
the plain shell would be fairly easy to make. any moving parts (keyboard and hinge) are where things get trickier.
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
<LunaVorax>
Adding usb-host, tv-out and wifi would make the ultimate pocket UNIX computer for me
<wpwrak>
having full design control over the keyboard would of course be very attractive. that's where customization is likely to be needed first.
<LunaVorax>
Maybe I should just get a Nokia C3 and start hacking it :o)
<wpwrak>
TV ?
<LunaVorax>
Yes
<LunaVorax>
TV/Video out, whatever name you want to call it
<wpwrak>
ah, VGA :)
<larsc>
composite
<wpwrak>
well, the ben sort of has that ;-)
<LunaVorax>
"sort of"
<LunaVorax>
The GCW-Zero has everything the Ben2 should have, except it's not shaped like a Ben
<wpwrak>
you could improve the existing code. you can probably make a good enough frame buffer that runs in the background. so it would be like a "real" display.
<LunaVorax>
Not right now, I'm a terrible terrible C coder
<LunaVorax>
And a disastrous UNIX coder
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 252 seconds]
<wpwrak>
sounds like a great learning opportunity :)
jekhor has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
<LunaVorax>
Hope you're right
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
<paul_boddie>
It might be nice if we could still channel some of the news and other goings-on through the qi-hardware site, though. When it is up, it looks almost static now.
<LunaVorax>
And the "planet" link on the wiki doesn't work for me
<paul_boddie>
No, I think the planet has been switched off.
<paul_boddie>
It was a bit heavy on the bandwidth, though. One huge, multi-month page with images every time is going to eat up bandwidth.
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
<larsc>
paul_boddie: so you just volunteered for the editor-in-chief position for QI News? ;)
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 264 seconds]
<paul_boddie>
Well, I do surf the Internet a bit, but lekernel's recent announcement was completely new to me. I guess I don't read enough Swedish VJ news to pick up on the really exciting stuff. ;-)
LunaVorax has left #qi-hardware ["Quitte"]
LunaVorax has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
Have any of you been following the Rhombus Tech project? They actually seem to have working hardware now.
<LunaVorax>
Link?
xdpirate has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
<larsc>
lekernel: see, you need to work on your PR strategy
<LunaVorax>
It's too bad, the planet link was very interesting
xdpirate has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
you'd have to hang out on #milkymist to see what's going on in the somewhat parallel universe
<LunaVorax>
What do you mean wpwrak
<LunaVorax>
Besides I don't own a Milkymist
<wpwrak>
that was for paul_boddie. milkymist-related things are mainly discussed there.
<paul_boddie>
Well, the idea is that they use a standard form factor like PCMCIA for upgradability reasons, so it's not completely like the RPi where people have to build their cases out of Lego and where the hardware is yet another board to be badly supported for the minimum possible time.
<paul_boddie>
If you want a RPi with A10 or similar, you could just go to Olimex and get something from them given that they've been doing that kind of thing for a while now. Or get the Cubieboard, or whatever.
<wpwrak>
kewl. that pcmcia connector alone probbaly costs more than the whole pcb should :)
<paul_boddie>
I guess they know about the pricing trade-offs. The assertion is that it's still mass-produced and lkcl seems to be pretty price-aware.
<paul_boddie>
We had a discussion about this a while back (maybe on the list), but people didn't think it would work for NanoNote 2.0. I guess that games console concept would indicate whether it would or not.
<wpwrak>
well, it's unshielded. so that's half the price. still a rather expensive item to have.
<paul_boddie>
I guess you'd have to read the front page of their site to get the full rationale for using PCMCIA. I think it's good that someone wants to explore this route, even if there's going to be a lot of naysaying about it.
<wpwrak>
well yes, if you do an exhaustive search on the state space, that guarantees that you'll find all the optimal solutions. so far, so good. but ... :)
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
If they manage to revive the KDE tablet idea with that work then just that, all by itself, may have been worth it.
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 264 seconds]
<paul_boddie>
Is the Milkymist IRC channel archived, by the way?
<paul_boddie>
As far as what LunaVorax was saying, I think things have changed quite a bit since 2009 or so, and lots of people are trying to make devices/gadgets now.
<paul_boddie>
It's not exactly all happening in a coordinated way, which I imagine was one of the motivations for Qi-Hw.
<paul_boddie>
And so there's a lot of stuff getting funded and made that probably is what people want, but it perhaps doesn't lead to very sustainable further development.
<paul_boddie>
In other words, you get yet another Arduino/RPi clone being made, with yet more hardware differences between the last variant and the new one, and everybody has to learn (or find out) the differences, upgrade their stuff, and so on.
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
dandon_ has joined #qi-hardware
dandon has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
dandon_ is now known as dandon
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
<LunaVorax>
Now maybe we should do something so that nice discussion we had won't fall into the trashbin of history
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 246 seconds]
<larsc>
'we should do' is a bit of a euphemism for 'yea, ok, it will probably never happen'
<wpwrak>
i think that's a rather accurate translation :)
<Fallenou>
=)
<hellekin>
yakafokon
<hellekin>
(the French translation)
<larsc>
that doesn't sound french
<Fallenou>
contraction of "il n'y a qu'à, il faut qu'on"
<larsc>
ah
<hellekin>
thank you Fallenou :)
<hellekin>
I was struggling with my French layout ;o)
<Fallenou>
-> "you only have to, we need to"
<Fallenou>
hehe :)
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Read error: Operation timed out]
kilae has quit [Quit: ChatZilla 0.9.90 [Firefox 20.0.1/20130409194949]]
<whitequark>
huh huh, openwrt got a great lot better since 2010
<whitequark>
their new web interface is amazing
<whitequark>
you can even configure wlans on the integrated switch
<whitequark>
*vlans
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
<larsc>
luci has been around for quite some time
<larsc>
It was even there in 2010
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 245 seconds]
<pcercuei>
whitequark: can you transfer files to/from the device on their web interface?
<whitequark>
larsc: in 2010 it was almost unusable
<whitequark>
pcercuei: I don't think I ever wanted that
<whitequark>
doesn't seem so
<whitequark>
but they finally have SCP
<LunaVorax>
Ok that was a seriously offending translation
<LunaVorax>
I'm genuinely concerned even if I don't have time to chat on #qi-hardware everyday
<LunaVorax>
Why so much cynism?
<LunaVorax>
On the other hand if there's no hope, explain to me, and that no joke, why #qi-hardware is still active
<wpwrak>
think of it as the neighbourhood pub where you go for a beer after the day's work is done
<wpwrak>
only that no beer is being served on #qi-hw, and you can tune in anytime you like
Jurting_pc2 has joined #qi-hardware
<whitequark>
(except that he didn't stomp on anyone, he fell from the sky. flakey translation.)
jekhor has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
russians are weird :)
<whitequark>
it's very absurd and funny. and I like her voice :)
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 264 seconds]
mirko has quit [Read error: Operation timed out]
mirko has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
<larsc>
LunaVorax: It's not cynism, if you want to get something done do it yourself and don't wait for others
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
LunaVorax has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ is now known as Calyp
Calyp has quit [Changing host]
Calyp has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
jekhor has quit [Ping timeout: 252 seconds]
megha has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp has quit [Ping timeout: 246 seconds]
<paul_boddie>
Well, I see the point being made, which is that people are fairly downbeat about stuff.
<paul_boddie>
There's not too much general enthusiasm any more, at least not compared to other groups of people. That's the impression one might get.
Calyp has joined #qi-hardware
baba has joined #qi-hardware
megha has quit [Ping timeout: 248 seconds]
wej has quit [Ping timeout: 260 seconds]
baba has quit [Quit: WeeChat 0.4.0]
Calyp has quit [Read error: Operation timed out]
coyo has joined #qi-hardware
coyo has quit [Changing host]
coyo has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
paul_boddie: i'd say that everybody involved so far has done what they can do. and it wasn't enough for the project to become sustainable. so choices are to burry the remains, perhaps keep the good bits while that's possible (e.g., downloads and the repositories are rather handy), or bring in people who can breathe new life into this project.
megha has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
For a strict definition of the project as being concerned with the Ben, I guess I have to agree: the engine has gone cold, as it were.
<paul_boddie>
I guess the lack of any particular focus at the moment, and the lack of energy in finding a new focus, means that there is going to be a sense of hibernation about the whole thing.
<wpwrak>
regarding the ya / next ben, i have a pretty clear idea of what to do, minus some things that may count as original research, e.g., the keyboard. all that needs is financing. that's something i'm not good at organizing. so there's my stopping block.
<viric>
In general, I never understood how can people group to do something together
<viric>
in my experience, either I do it, or noone will. :)
Calyp has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
I don't see why various groups don't work together: I see them struggling, and it would be so much easier for them to team up. The only problem is the existing investment everyone has.
<wpwrak>
the ben's engine has been cooling for a long while. i tried to put a bit of spark into it at the beginning of this year, with the various ubb projects, but the response was a bit underwhelming. paul_boddie, the medal of the only one caring to even react to all that pretty much goes to you :)
<wpwrak>
viric: a lot of people like to follow strong leaders. so that's the image you have to project.
<paul_boddie>
wpwrak: Well, I did like your different ideas at making open hardware projects interesting and accessible to people.
<viric>
I either fail at giving that image, or I didn't find such people :)
<wpwrak>
viric: i think the blame's on you :) the planet is full of followers ...
<viric>
damn it, I'm not a leader.
<paul_boddie>
Say what you like about lkcl, for example, but the guy is stubborn. That means that his PCMCIA initiative will either succeed or fail in style, but he seems to be relentless.
<wpwrak>
viric: of course, an effective leader also has to be slightly psychotic. maybe you're just not demented enough :)
<viric>
wpwrak: I've to acknowledge that I'm quite alone in *using* the software I developed. For me it's a must-have, and very rarely other people like it :)
<viric>
wpwrak: ah yes, that's a very plausible explanation ;)
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
mog has joined #qi-hardware
mog has quit [Changing host]
mog has joined #qi-hardware
<wpwrak>
paul_boddie: i think the question is whether he'll run out of resources before a decision point will be reached
<wpwrak>
viric: lack of mass appeal could create some difficulties :)
<paul_boddie>
wpwrak: The guy is stubborn, as I said - it's almost personal for him now, I think. He also might have made the right connections to secure sufficient resources.
unclouded has joined #qi-hardware
<viric>
wpwrak: right. I'm not trying to lead a project about a banana keyboard
<paul_boddie>
What he's doing isn't really unusual: lots of people seem to be making their own boards these days. But if he can pull in enough domain experts to get that KDE tablet out there, it will demonstrate a capability at a different level.
<wpwrak>
paul_boddie: well, it depends on what he's selling. if he's selling those modules, i'm sceptical. if he's selling the design behind them, i think he's in a much better position.
<wpwrak>
selling = offering and having a buyer
<paul_boddie>
wpwrak: It's both. The controversial thing about it is that he wants people to make their own, which is good, but his organisation supposedly reserves the right to the concept via a couple of patents, which is not good.
Calyp has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
<wpwrak>
hah ;-)
<wpwrak>
well, investors like patents.
<wpwrak>
but they're also good at cutting off dead branches
<wpwrak>
so ...
<paul_boddie>
I'd be supportive (not just reporting what he's been up to) if he made the licensing status clear and reassured everyone that they aren't going to get sued if they adopt his proposed standard.
<paul_boddie>
But up to this point such reassurances have been intangible and vague, when they actually need to be concrete and specific as we all know.
<wpwrak>
in fact, i wasn't aware of those issues. my scepticism comes from the potential merits of the project even before considering those evil bits
<wpwrak>
so he's basically trying to trap people. oh well, the industry is full of that
<paul_boddie>
I think a modular standard makes some kind of sense. We've had it in various forms over the years, and you could probably get a lot of mileage out of it for lots of devices before it might become too inflexible.
wej has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
I think that there's even the idea that it should be a family of form factors, not just PCMCIA. That is just a pragmatic choice of the first generation of gadgetry, I believe.
<paul_boddie>
But anyway, with regard to things like leadership and financing, I don't think we lack people doing open hardware who can do these things. For example, the Golden Delicious people doing the GTA04 clearly have the ability to finance something which can be regarded as comparable to the Ben.
<paul_boddie>
And similarly, you have the OpenPandora people. And the GCW-Zero people. And the Rhombus Tech people, although arguably in a more opaque fashion.
<wpwrak>
yes, they have a working business that can finance their adventures
<wpwrak>
i don't know about how sustainable the others are
megha has quit [Quit: WeeChat 0.4.0]
<paul_boddie>
(I was doing some UBB stuff yesterday, but ran out of steam. Despite having a strategy, I think my electronics skills are lacking and/or my target was a bit too ambitious, and I started to wonder what I was really going to achieve, anyway.)
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 276 seconds]
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
Caly__ has quit [Ping timeout: 256 seconds]
Caly__ has joined #qi-hardware
Calyp_ has quit [Ping timeout: 252 seconds]
Calyp_ has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
Beyond a certain point, there's only so much someone can realistically do for themself, though, if they are really interested in some project succeeding.
LunaVorax has joined #qi-hardware
<paul_boddie>
People can only bring what they know to the table, and perhaps commit to learning other things, but that doesn't get a project with lots of different aspects going strong, let alone finished.